Date	Winner	Margin	Jockey	Wt.	Second	Third	Nominations	Starters	Net to Winner	Time	Track
May 17, 1875	Aristides	2 lengths	O. Lewis	100	Volcano	Verdigris	42	15	$2,850	2:37¾	Fast
May 15, 1876	Vagrant	2 lengths	B. Swim	97	Creedmore	Harry Hill	34	11	2,950	2:38¼	Fast
May 22, 1877	Baden-Baden	2 lengths	W. Walker	100	Leonard	King William	41	11	3,300	2:38	Fast
May 21, 1878	Day Star	1 length	J. Carter	100	Himyar	Leveler	56	9	4,050	2:37¼	Dusty
May 20, 1879	Lord Murphy	1 length	C. Shauer	100	Falsetto	Strathmore	46	9	3,550	2:37	Fast
May 18, 1880	Fonso	7 lengths	G. Lewis	105	Kimball	Bancroft	47	5	3,800	2:37½	Dusty
May 17, 1881	Hindoo	4 lengths	J. McLaughlin	105	Lelex	Alfambra	62	6	4,410	2:40	Fast
May 16, 1882	Apollo	1½ lengths	B. Hurd	102	Runnymede	Bengal	64	14	4,560	240¼	Good
May 23, 1883	Leonatus	3 lengths	W. Donohue	105	Drake Carter	Lord Raglan	50	7	3,760	2:43	Heavy
May 16, 1884	Buchanan	1 length	I. Murphy	110	Loftin	Audrain	51	9	3,990	2:40¼	Good
May 14, 1885	Joe Cotton	Neck	E. Henderson	110	Bersan	Ten Booker	69	10	4,630	237¼	Good
May 14, 1886	Ben Ali	½ length	P. Duffy	118	Blue Wing	Free Knight	107	10	4,890	236½	Fast
May 11, 1887	Montrose	2 lengths	I. Lewis	118	Jim Gore	Jacobin	86	7	4,200	239¼	Fast
May 14, 1888	Macbeth II	1 length	G. Covington	115	Gallifet	White	95	7	4,740	238¼	Fast
May 9, 1889	Spokane	Nose	T. Kiley	118	Proctor Knott	Once Again	94	8	4,880	2:34½	Fast
May 14, 1890	Riley	1¾ lengths	I. Murphy	118	Bill Letcher	Robespierre	115	6	5,460	2:45	Muddy
May 13, 1891	Kingman	½ length	I. Murphy	122	Balgowan	High Tariff	83	4	4,550	252¼	Slow
May 11, 1892	Azra	Nose	A. Clayton	122	Huron	Phil Dwyer	68	3	4,230	2:41½	Heavy
May 10, 1893	Lookout	4 lengths	E. Kunze	122	Plutus	Boundless	60	6	3,840	2:39¼	Fast
May 15, 1894	Chant	6 lengths	F. Goodale	122	Pearl Song	Sigurd	55	5	4,020	2:41	Fast
May 6, 1895	Halma	5 lengths	J. Perkins	122	Basso	Laureate	57	4	2,970	2:37½	Fast
May 6, 1896	Ben Brush	Nose	W. Simms	117	Ben Eder	Semper Ego	171	8	4,850	2:07¾	Dusty
May 12, 1897	Typhoon II	Neck	F. Garner	117	Ornament	Dr. Catlett	159	6	4,850	2:12½	Heavy
May 4, 1898	Plaudit	Nose	W. Simms	117	Lieber Karl	Isabey	179	4	4,850	2:09	Good
May 4, 1899	Manuel	2 lengths	F. Taral	117	Corsini	Mazo	151	5	4,850	2:12	Fast
May 3, 1900	Lieut. Gibson	3 lengths	J. Boland	117	Florizar	Thrive	131	7	4,850	2:06¼	Fast

| 1875-1900 | 1901-1925 | 1926-1950 | 1951-1975 | 1976-2004 |